#1 Pin
When a DeMolay is a first-line signer on his first petition and the person petitioning joins DeMolay, the DeMolay who signed the petition receives the #1 Pin.

Membership Merit Bars
When a DeMolay is the first line signer on three petitions for individuals who join DeMolay, the DeMolay receives a white merit bar. For each additional three members brought in, the next color of merit bar is earned.

Founder's Membership Award
When a DeMolay is the first line signer on five petitions for individuals who join DeMolay, the DeMolay receives the Founder's Membership Award, an attractive medallion featuring the founder of DeMolay, Frank S. Land.

Blue Honor Key
When a DeMolay is the first line signer on ten petitions for individuals who join DeMolay, the DeMolay receives the Blue Honor Key. For each additional ten members brought in, a star is added to the Blue Honor Key.

Pink Honor Key
When a female supporter of DeMolay "side-line" signs five petitions for individuals who join DeMolay, she receives the Pink Honor Key.